Thursday, June 20, 2013
Search The Archives
Log In

Register new account

Request new password

Publishers
Editors
Majority Reporters
Latest Reports
Steven Maviglio

Governor's Race: The Early Line on 2010

November 08, 2006 @ 9:40 AM
Steven Maviglio

Now that the election is over, the talk of the town has quickly turned to the post-Arnold era 2010 gubernatorial election.
 
On the Republican side, newly minted Insurance Commissioner Steve Poizner already is the early favorite by virtue of an unlimited bankroll to fund his campaign. But the GOP's conservative wing will surely have their say about challenging him at some point. With who is not clear, particularly given the blowout of the weak Republican bench in statewide contests last night.
 
Here's our early line on the 2010 Governor's race:

Antonio Villaraigosa 4-1 -- No surprise here. The LA Mayor has had his eye on the horseshoe since he was in utero. The energizer bunny of California politics, he starts off with a strong base in LA, sky-high popularity ratings, instant appeal to Latino voters statewide, and connections to the resources he needs to run the race in both LA and Sacramento. Villariagosa has put his chips on turning LA's troubled schools around, but pundits say it will be difficult to measure change in the time frame before he ramps up his run for Governor. Villariagosa helped a number of candidates in this year's election, taping radio ads and appearing in direct mail pieces. But he also had a cozy relationship with Schwarzenegger and endorsed Angelides post Labor Day, which sparked some static among party stalwarts Also on the downside, as mayor of the state's largest city, there also are dozens of land mines he'll have to circumnavigate in the next few years. Remember too that LA mayors never have had an easy time making the leap into the governor's office either.
 
Gavin Newsom 6-1 -- San Francisco's suave mayor says he hasn't decided whether to run for re-election yet, never mind the Governor's office. Yet Newsom has to be considered a top contender if he takes the plunge. Like Antonio, Newsom is off-the-charts in popularity. Sure, gay marriage put him on the map, but he's been an innovative policymaker as well, delving into health care and homeless issues. He's also a darling of the media, which certainly doesn't hurt. What other mayor makes it into People on a regular basis? However, unless he wants a classic Northern California vs. Southern California contest, he'll have to compete for votes in LA, San Diego, and the Central Valley -- all of which could be problematic.
 
Bill Lockyer 10-1 -- The Attorney General-turned-Treasurer wisely sat out of a gubernatorial run during this election cycle -- and also sat on upwards of $8 million in cash, causing some party insiders to grumble that he wasn't helping the Democratic ticket enough. Still, that bank account will come in handy when he makes his own expected run in 2010. Lockyer will have a smaller bully pulpit at the treasurer’s office, but it will keep him closely connected to his labor allies and in the media spotlight. Lockyer has a populist independent streak (voting for Schwarzenegger in the recall, criticizing the “puke politics" of Gray Davis) that hasn't endeared him to many party faithful. But he's a strong vote getter when the chips are down and has a wealth of accomplishments to tout.
 
Jack O'Connell 25-1 -- Nice guy Jack O'Connell has used his perch as the Superintendent of Public Education well, positioning himself as the champion of public education. He's also been extremely active in supporting Democratic candidates up and down the tickets; he'll have a ton of chits to call in. He can't compete with the charisma of either mayor, but he has a solid reputation and enjoys broad support. O'Connell may be everybody's second choice -- the kind of candidate that could squeak into the office if there's an ugly primary.
 
John Garamendi 25-1 -- By virtue of his LG victory, Garamendi instantly is a contender. He's longed for the corner office for ages. After a successful run as Insurance Commissioner, he'll no doubt use the LG's office to pump up his profile. But Garamendi doesn't have the resources or charisma to compete with either mayor, and it will be an uphill battle.
 
Jerry Brown 25-1 -- The night's top vote getter, Brown instantly vaults into the favorites column by virtue of his name ID. Brown hasn't made any noise about wanting to be Governor, but then again, you wouldn't expect him too. Chances are that he'll find a comfortable niche as AG and run for re-election. But in a crowded field, Brown certainly could emerge the winner.
 
Steve Westly 50-1 -- Rumor has it that Westly is eyeing the U.S. Senate rather than the governorship, but we'll keep his name on the front burner until we hear otherwise. Westly narrowly lost the June primary to Angelides, but instead of going into hiding, he's kept his political operation alive. He's formed a PAC that funneled funds into the races of several up-and-coming Democrats. He’s graciously hosted fundraisers for Angelides in the Silicon Valley and did a last minute campaign trip through the Central Valley as well. Westly's bank account makes him a viable contender -- especially if fellow Silicon Valley entrepreneur Steve Poizner leaps into the Governor's race as expected.

Loretta Sanchez 50-1 -- The Orange County Congresswoman opened a committee last year and made some noise about running. She has some appeal as a Latina with Washington credentials. But now that Democrats have taken over the House, it's difficult to imagine that Sanchez will give up her seat at a longshot run at the Governorship.
 
Other Players:
 
Dianne Feinstein 50-1 -- If she's in, she wins. End of story. She's got the name, the money, and the clout to scare everyone else out of the race. 2010 would be her last likely shot at ending her career in her home state. But the new Senate may give her more reason than ever to stay in Washington.
 
Fabian Nunez 100-1 -- If you believe the black helicopter theories being advanced by Dan Walters and other columnists, the Speaker isn't running for Governor but simply wants to fill Antonio's shoes at LA City Hall when he runs for Governor. The Speaker is termed out in 2008. What he'll do after that is anyone's guess.
 
John Chiang 100-1 -- He's controller. And what happens to controllers? They run for Governor (ask Gray Davis and Steve Westly). Nobody is throwing his name around yet, but stranger things have happened.
 
Debra Bowen 100-1 -- Same story here. Bowen will likely stay on the job as Secretary of State, but the Governorship would be tempting if it's an all-male revue.
 
Jackie Speier 100-1 -- Speier's second place finish in the LG's race this year doesn't portend well for a future Governor's race. She had a difficult time raising cash during her last go-round and it will be even harder once out of office. Still, she is woman, hear her roar. I don't think we've seen the last of her on the statewide scene, and that's a good thing for Democrats. Speier has a compelling story and was an effective legislator.


Phil Angelides 250-1 -- Richard Nixon, Dianne Feinstein, and Bill Clinton are among those who suffered stinging defeats, only to run again. Never say never.

Print this report | Send to a friend

About Steven Maviglio | All Reports by Steven Maviglio



Browse in : [ Reports ]

Note: Comments are owned by the poster. We are not responsible for their content.

You must be logged in to comment. You may log in or create an account.

Governor's Race: The Early Line on 2010

Posted by: AngelicaG on November 08, 2006

Steve -- You listed all the obvious elected officials, but do you see any gazillionaire types making a run for Gov? Any more actors, like, oh, Ben Affleck? (A girl can dream...)

#

Governor's Race: The Early Line on 2010

Posted by: Steven Maviglio on November 08, 2006

Not with such a strong lineup of Democratic pols. Plus, haven't we had enough of actors??!!

#

The roles of Nunez?

Posted by: SFBrianCL on November 08, 2006

By the by, do oddsmakers usually work for the athletes? Not that I think your odds are off, except maybe the Gav. I gotta think that he would avoid a confrontation with Villaraigosa and he would also be a great candidate for Senator. We need to ensure that we have a strong candidate for Senate in 2010 as the rumors about Arnold running have been fast and furious. Hey, Senator Nunez wouldn't sound too bad, either, would it? Speaking of a talent for legislating...

And Steve, thanks for your good work with the Angelides campaign. I know that this race was an incredibly challenging situation, with Arnold co-opting the Democratic message. It's great that you were able to get involved, even if it might have been too little too late.

#

Governor's Race: The Early Line on 2010

Posted by: Randy on November 09, 2006

Too early for this stuff, but here's my two-cents.

Villaraigosa blew his chance with the LA schools takeover and hopefully the party won't forget how much help he wasn't to Angelides. Nunez too, though the party wasn't much help either.

Look for Garamendi and O'Connell to move in from the outside.

And yes, you did forget the non-pols...

#

Governor's Race: The Early Line on 2010

Posted by: Matt Jones on November 09, 2006

Steve indirectly makes the best point. I think once Villaraigosa starts running, his campaign will run out of steam quickly as people realize how weak his qualifications, biography, and achievements really are in comparison to some of our other veteran lawmakers. Lockyer has an amazing record of service, as does Garamendi, and Gavin could be putting us all on about not running. LA in general, and LAUSD specifically, will hang Villaraigosa - and the greatest indignity is that he fought to get that albatross around his neck, all the while pissing off the teachers' union.

#

Governor's Race: The Early Line on 2010

Posted by: The Chief on November 09, 2006

I think Randy & Matt are sniffing some crazy glue.

Even if Villaraigosa campaigned everyday for Angelides you'd see him lose -- so let's not play that game.

Everyone across the state saw the LA Mayor campaign hard for good progressive propositions and even lead the IE campaign for John Chiang.

As for the LAUSD being an albatross -- i suspect our fellow bloggers aren't familiar with Ray Cortines.

#

Governor's Race: The Early Line on 2010

Posted by: Donald Lathbury on November 09, 2006

I suspect the late endorsement of Angelides will anger Sac insiders (of which this blog attracts disproportionate numbers for obvious reasons), but I can't imagine that will resonate in the minds of the lay voter in the slightest four years down the road.

#

Governor's Race: The Early Line on 2010

Posted by: david_t on November 09, 2006

If Gavin and Antonio run against each other, you will find surprisingly strong support *for Gavin* in Los Angeles. Wouldn't the party be better off if these two focused on the Senate seats, and let Garamendi or O'Connell be governor? GN and AV would be one hell of a dynamic duo in Washington.

#

Governor's Race: The Early Line on 2010

Posted by: kmoros1989 on November 09, 2006

ok- I know you will all laugh at me, but having worked on the Treasurer's campaign as a 17 year old, I believe in his vision for California. I believe he should give it another shot in 2010, when he most likely wont have to face an Actor with 100% name recognition. I think its fair to say that the Treasurer would have won if facing a non-famous Republican. Anyway, if Treaurer Angelides decides to give it another shot, I'll be behind him from the onnset.

#

Governor's Race: The Early Line on 2010

Posted by: david_t on November 10, 2006

kmoros -- While Angelides may well have won if he had faced a Republican who was neither an incumbent nor a global superstar married to a Kennedy, there is little appetite in the party for a re-run. Of course, if he chooses to stay involved (and I hope he does, one way or another), it's always possible that things could change. (Nixon became president six years after losing the governorship, and vowing that the press would never have him to kick around anymore.) At this point, however, you'd have to say that the 2010 nomination is a very high mountain for Phil to climb.

#

Governor's Race: The Early Line on 2010

Posted by: Bill Bradley on November 12, 2006

Well, Steve, considering your prognostications in the governor's race et al ... :)

These are interesting but very flawed assessments.

#

Governor's Race: The Early Line on 2010

Posted by: Steven Maviglio on November 13, 2006

Bill: I predicted all of the top of the ticket offices correctly. Which is more than I can say for your site!

#

Governor's Race: The Early Line on 2010

Posted by: miller900 on November 13, 2006

Quick question on Brown... Is he able to be governor, what with term limits?

#

Yes, Jerry Can Run

Posted by: Steven Maviglio on November 14, 2006

He was Governor before the term limits law went into effect. So yes, he can run. See the Oak Tribune article today for more details.

#

Governor's Race: The Early Line on 2010

Posted by: Bill Bradley on November 14, 2006

Steve, my friend, you are simply unbelievable! Your endless wrongheaded, misleading spin on my site and elsewhere was quite a performance. In addition to wasting my time, it bled your credibility, as I warned you privately.

And don't forget you picked Angelides to come back.

#

Governor's Race: The Early Line on 2010

Posted by: Bill Bradley on November 14, 2006

Oh, and as you know, I report tracking polls, accurately, leaving readers to make their own judgments. Those tracking polls included -- in fact, were mostly -- the Democratic tracking polls. As you know very well, having sat right next to me at the Thursday post-mortem as I described the process and never having disputed my reporting of the polls during the campaign.(Though you did trash the Field Poll, and constantly sent out those Mickey Mouse polls to credulous journos and bloggers who immediately published them.) I had no wrong "picks." There were a few races that were toss-ups.

If this site is going to succeed, it is going to have to be more than kneejerk partisan spin. I promoted it at the start expecting more of a broad-ranging, sophisticated discussion, not governorphil.com on steroids.

#

Re: Governor's Race: The Early Line on 2010

Posted by: atdnext on November 14, 2006

So Mr. Bradley, were you expecting everyone here to bash Angelides the way you and your friends were doing on NWN EVERY SINGLE DAY, on EVERY SINGLE POST? Sorry, but this is supposed to be a Democratic site! I must admit that I wasn't all that impressed with this site early on, but I think CMR has been getting better in offering good insight. At least here, I know where they're coming from, and I know their viewpoints... They don't hide their bias and pretend that it's "impartial, independent analysis", and I appreciate that.

#

Governor's Race: Villaraigosa v. Newsom

Posted by: atdnext on November 14, 2006

Hmmm... This would be a really tough choice for me. While I've been a big fan of Villaraigosa since he won the LA Mayor's race last year, I've also been a big fan of Newsom since he stood up for marriage equality in early 2004. They're both such strong candidates... Hopefully one of them will ultimately step aside (and possibly run for Senate when Feinstein or Boxer retires?).

Oh, and thanks Mr. Maviglio, for including my Congresswoman on the list... I know that Loretta hasn't always been content with just being our Congresswoman in Central OC... Down here, we've heard the rumors as well. While on one hand, I'd love to see Loretta as our next Governor, on the other hand I don't want to lose her as my Representative. Besides, Loretta now has power in Washington... And a cozy seat on the Homeland Security Committee!

#

Governor's Race: The Early Line on 2010

Posted by: Bill Bradley on November 14, 2006

I called the governor's race accurately from the start, and at every turn.

In part because I knew the polls, and knew what was real and what was, at best, misleading BS.

If you can't handle the truth, you won't like it.

#

Re: Governor's Race: Villaraigosa v. Newsom

Posted by: Robert Chang on November 18, 2006

I do agree Newsom is stronger than Villaraigosa. The Hispanic vote is not that strong to but Villaraigosa in office, and Villaraigosa, despite his recent moves toward the center, still turns off a lot of moderate Democrats. Newsom's Care Not Cash strategy and the universal health care have both appeal to liberals and moderates, and will have a good track record come 2010, whereas we won't see anything with the Villaraigosa Subway to the Sea, nor will we see too much happen with the schools by the 2010 campaign.

#

Governor's Race: The Early Line on 2010

Posted by: AnswerMan on November 08, 2008

December 4th Newsom announces his run for Governor. Confirmed. Smart money is elsewhere.

#

Ratings

The Majority Vote
Who is the biggest loser of the 2012 election cycle?

Results

Majority Vote Archives

BlogTalkRadio
Listen to California Majority Reports on internet talk radio
The Echo Chamber
For the Week of February 3, 2008
Latest Comments